THEATRE REVIEW: King Lear starring Kenneth Branagh at Wyndham’s Theatre

By Neil Durham

WORTH A LOOK?: ***

WHEN?: Saturday 21 October, opens 31 October and runs through 9 December 2023 RUNTIME: 120 minutes without interval

At 62 years old director Branagh is considerably younger than the last 2 actors we’ve seen take on the role of Shakespeare’s King Lear – Sir Ian McKellen who was 78 in 2017 and the late Glenda Jackson 80 in 2016.

  • Read on for reasons including how Branagh’s casting is less A Haunting In Venice and more a vanity in London

Interviewed in the programme Derek Jacobi, ‘Lear class of 2010’, says : ‘When you’re a young classical actor, you go through the Hamlet hoop. If your Hamlet is anywhere near all right, then you’re admitted to the classical club. Towards the end of your career, you’ve got to go through the Lear hoop to confirm they were right to let you in.’

We haven’t seen Branagh in the West End since The Kenneth Branagh Company’s year-long run of six plays at the Garrick Theatre closed in 2016 on its highest high with its star taking the lead in The Entertainer.

His 3rd outing as Agatha Christie’s beloved Belgian detective Hercule Poirot in A Haunting In Venice has recently topped the UK’s cinema box office and this autumn we very much enjoyed its predecessor Death On The Nile.

In fact Branagh can probably lay claim to being 1 of Hollywood’s biggest stars now with a career that boasts an incredible tally of an Oscar, 4 BAFTAs, 2 Emmys, a Golden Globe and an Olivier Award.

His relative youth then means that his Lear, which plays for 50 performances at the intimate 759-capacity Wyndham’s Theatre in London’s West End, has a lot of convincing to do as the king who asks his daughters what they think of him, doesn’t like the answer and triggers a chain of events that will see his descent into madness.

Branagh’s Lear is cinematic rather than theatrical with its duration curtailed cleverly into a single sitting usually devoted to seeing a film rather than some of the more sprawling and self-indulgent Lears that we have seen.

The production’s look is TV’s Game Of Thrones meets The Walking Dead with the ‘sticks and stones’ references that litter Shakespeare’s text taken a little too literally with a Stonehenge-like backdrop and more staffs on a stage than you could wave a stick at, although you probably couldn’t find a spare 1 at the Wyndham’s because they were all being used by the cast.

At 1 point as Lear’s madness takes its hold, the bearded Branagh with ruffled hair is stripped topless revealing a sturdy and muscular frame that underlines the problem here: we simply weren’t convinced by Lear’s fate given his lack of years despite Branagh’s worthy 1st attempt at the role.

If Trump gets the Republican nomination, we can see why Branagh’s thoughts about Lear’s parallels with the former US president make it an appetising prospect to stage on Broadway (see teaser trailer above and interview immediately above) ahead of the November 2024 US election but we think rather than the sound of an incoming storm it is of theatrical box-ticking that we can hear throughout this production.

We can see the appeal, but like McKellen who returned to Lear with much greater success 2nd time around, we think Branagh very much needs to do the same.

While we appreciate the motivation, in the words of his latest cinematic success, we think his Lear was less A Haunting In Venice and more a vanity in London.

  • Main picture via Facebook courtesy DMT Tickets
  • Have you ever been to the Wyndhams Theatre before or seen Kenneth Branagh onstage? Let us know what you thought in the comments below
  • Enjoyed this review? Follow monstagigz on Twitter @monstagigz, email neildurham3@gmail.com and check us out on Instagram and Facebook

Discover more from monstagigz

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

9 comments

  1. Pingback: 9 reasons why we can’t wait for October 2023 starring Kenneth Branagh as King Lear | monstagigz
  2. Nina Dunn's avatar
    Nina Dunn · October 22, 2023

    How dare you post any sort of a review after a first preview?! Reviews are embragoed until after the official press night on 31st October. Terrible disrespect for theatre protocol and entirely unprofessional. I imagine the producers will come after you and request you take this down.

    Like

    • John Forbes's avatar
      John Forbes · October 27, 2023

      This is an unspoken rule, not a law. If the Wyndham’s are charging full price for their preview tickets, they should expect to be scrutinised.

      Liked by 1 person

    • mrmonstagigz's avatar
      mrmonstagigz · November 1, 2023

      Thank you for your comments. We value the thoughts of all who read us and hope we have addressed them below. We trust you’ve seen the rather less kind 1* reviews of this production in The Stage and the Mail today?

      Like

  3. Dan M's avatar
    Dan M · October 28, 2023

    Having seen the performance on Oct 26th I’m surprised by the tone of this review. I thought the production superb in every way, all the actors quite excellent and Branagh nothing short of astonishing.

    Like

  4. kristensene's avatar
    kristensene · October 28, 2023

    I saw the 10/28 matinee and I loved it. There is more going on in the story than the actions and words of one character. And the cast, top to bottom, provide a compelling, and moving, performance. Look, I could be wrong, but the entire house gave them a standing ovation. Is it the ultimate production of Lear, maybe not…but an argument can be made that no such thing exists and that is why it has been regularly re-staged for centuries. If it’s up to you, do not miss this production.

    Like

  5. etherp's avatar
    etherp · October 29, 2023

    The most uncomfortable theatre seats I can remember, but a wonderful imaginative performance.

    Like

  6. mrmonstagigz's avatar
    mrmonstagigz · October 30, 2023

    Thank you to everyone who has taken the time to read – and comment. As a paying customer who has enjoyed many Kenneth Branagh productions, I publish a mixture of press night reviews and preview reviews because we think it’s important to give readers a sense of what the public might experience and not just what is chosen to be appropriate for critics on a certain night.

    We appreciate a 3* review of a 1st preview is not ideal and we agonise over whether to publish such material, generally seeking only to enhance rather than diminish a show in previews and certainly wouldn’t review lower than 3*.

    We have been asked to take this review down by the show’s publicists but this was not a press ticket and so we don’t feel bound by any embargo.

    Perhaps productions should consider not charging for previews if the experience is going to be less than is hoped for from a select band of critics on one particular evening?

    Like

  7. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: King Lear starring Danny Sapani & Clarke Peters at the Almeida | monstagigz

Leave a reply to Nina Dunn Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.