THEATRE REVIEW: Hamilton starring Jamael Westman


WHERE: Victoria Palace

WHEN: 26/12, booking to 28/7/18

The good news is that the touts appear to have been beaten – and the bad is that it’s the most uncomfortable wait to enter a theatre we can ever remember.

  • Read on for reasons including how King George’s Britpop number is the comic highlight

Our instructions advise us to arrive at 6.30pm, an hour before curtain up. We do so along with the majority of the rest of the audience and queue for 25 minutes in the pouring rain without an umbrella. Our bad.

By the time we reach the front of the queue we’re soaked through and our mobile phone is so wet it’s struggling to summon up our confirmation email but it does so eventually – and we’re in.

We go to a lot of theatre and there’s an audible crackle in the air, a mix of youthful excitement and enthusiasm from all ages, that we don’t think we’ve ever encountered before.

‘How does a bastard, orphan, son of a whore and a Scotsman, dropped in the middle of a forgotten spot in the Caribbean by Providence, impoverished, in squalor grow up to be a hero and a scholar?’

It’s the first rap sung in this much-hailed musical and proves a neat summary of Act One, the rise of Alexander Hamilton to become one of America’s founding fathers in the 18th century – before his, spoiler alert, Act Two downfall.

Our low-key quest to discover what it was about this dense, historical musical tale that made it so special started with its predecessor In The Heights, which we saw twice in London in 2015.

It was set in the predominantly Dominican-American neighbourhood Washington Heights and it’s a contemporary musical which means rapping and street dancing on a joyous scale.

Born in New York, composer, lyricist and playwright Lin Manuel-Miranda, who is of Puerto-Rican descent, won four Tonys for that breakthrough musical in 2008.

It was its sense of community values in an immigrant neighbourhood which chimed most in our heart during the two performances we saw in King’s Cross in 2015.

In Hamilton, it’s clear what drew Manuel-Miranda to the story: it’s very much in the rap tradition of outsider with nothing makes good and, with a Shakespearean flourish, the trait that propels their rise sows the seeds of their downfall.

What distinguishes it from In The Heights is that it uses the hip hop and rap so well realised there but transfers it to 18th century America where a multicultural cast runs riot with it. For us the musical template is a little Eminem circa 8 Mile (2002, fact fans) but we understand that within musical theatre circles that this is considered somehow revolutionary.

We worried before seeing it this evening that there was so much that Brits would find hard to love about it. However the Britpop-inspired You’ll Be Back sung wonderfully snippishly by Michael Jibson as King George is the comic highlight.

It’s a show in need of comedy because it takes itself very seriously. Some of the politics passed us by. Jason Pennycooke as a dandyish Thomas Jefferson observes at one point that he can’t follow the complexities of Hamilton’s work and we’re with him on that one. At times this seems over complicated.

But for every wrong move Manuel-Miranda has a lyrical flourish that will leave you catching your breath and the rap battles with which much of the densest politics is dissected is at least a blast.

We’d love for the Schuyler sisters to have more to do. Angelica (a fierce Rachel John who we last saw in The Bodyguard) accomplishes much with the explanation of why she and Hamilton won’t work.

We enjoyed Giles Terera in both Pure Imagination and Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom and here, as Hamilton’s nemesis Burr, he has the part of a lifetime with which he does justice. Novice lead Jamael Westman (centre, main picture above) convinces but is occasionally flat tonight. There’s strength in depth in the cast and we’d give honourable mentions to the ferocious rapping of Tarinn Callender and Obioma Ugoala.

At two hours and 45 minutes with a 15-minute interval, we came away thinking it was at least a quarter of an hour too long and that the inevitable standing ovation was more for the scale of the ambition rather than how it is realised.

We suspect that, like Les Miserables with which it has much in common, Hamilton will become the sort of show that people who only go to the theatre once a year will want to see. And that it will run. And run.

  • Picture via YouTube courtesy Hamilton UK. Tickets
  • Enjoyed this review? Follow its author on Twitter @NeilDurham, email and check us out on Instagram and Facebook


  1. Pingback: OFF BROADWAY: THEATRE REVIEW: Mother of the Maid starring Glenn Close at the Public Theater | monstagigz
  2. Pingback: FILM REVIEW: Mary Poppins Returns starring Emily Blunt, Lin Manuel-Miranda & Ben Whishaw | monstagigz
  3. Pingback: PREVIEW: 9 reasons why we can’t wait for February 2019 | monstagigz
  4. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: Tokyo Rose at the New Diorama Theatre | monstagigz
  5. Pingback: Q&A and TV PREVIEW: His Dark Materials featuring Ruth Wilson, Dafne Keen & Sir Philip Pullman at the BFI | monstagigz
  6. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: & Juliet at the Shaftesbury Theatre starring Miriam-Teak Lee, Cassidy Janson, Oliver Tompsett & David Bedella | monstagigz
  7. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: Cinderella starring Rufus Hound at Turbine Theatre | monstagigz
  8. Pingback: TOP 10: Best read monstagigz content of 2020 starring Richard Armitage | monstagigz
  9. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: Treason – The Musical starring Bradley Jaden, Lucie Jones, Oliver Tompsett and Daniel Boys | monstagigz
  10. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: Black Matter starring Giles Terera | monstagigz
  11. Pingback: PREVIEW: 9 reasons why we can’t wait for June 2021 starring Constellations | monstagigz
  12. Pingback: FILM REVIEW: In The Heights starring Anthony Ramos, Melissa Barrera & Leslie Grace | monstagigz
  13. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: The Drifters Girl starring Beverley Knight, Adam J Bernard & Matt Henry at the Garrick Theatre | monstagigz
  14. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: Bring It On – The Musical starring Amber Davies & Louis Smith at Southbank Centre | monstagigz
  15. Pingback: PREVIEW/PREDICTIONS: Eurovision Song Contest pre-qualified finalists starring Chanel, Sam Ryder, Mahmood and Blanco | monstagigz
  16. Pingback: PREVIEW/PREDICTIONS: Eurovision Song Contest 2022 Final starring Cornelia Jakobs, Sam Ryder and Chanel | monstagigz
  17. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: Patriots starring Tom Hollander at Almeida Theatre | monstagigz
  18. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: Sylvia starring Beverley Knight and Sharon Rose at the Old Vic | monstagigz
  19. Pingback: 9 reasons why we can’t wait for June 2023 starring A Strange Loop | monstagigz

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.