THEATRE REVIEW: A Christmas Carol starring Rhys Ifans, John Dagleish and Golda Rosheuvel

WORTH A LOOK?: *****

WHERE: Old Vic

WHEN: 28/11, press night 29/11, runs to 20/1/18

Providing family entertainment with a message has been the aim of Old Vic artistic director Matthew Warchus since succeeding Kevin Spacey in 2015.

  • Read on for reasons including how 54,000 free mince pies feature in this production

Before this last preview he tells us this version of A Christmas Carol, which he also directs, was something of a late replacement for an unnamed venture which fell through.

He approached author Jack Thorne (who also wrote Harry Potter and The Cursed Child, opening on Broadway in April), giving him just five weeks to complete an adaptation.

Happily for all concerned this traditional take on Dickens, with 54,000 free mince pies throughout the run, abundant Christmas carols and joyous handbell ringing, is a triumphant tale of social conscience realised beautifully in 2017.

Our favourite Old Vic musical (High Society in 2015) was in the round and the staging here is similar. Two walkways stretch the length and breadth of the theatre, with the audience right at the heart of the action, and multiple lanterns hanging overhead.

The play begins with Scrooge returning a pile of money boxes into the gaps in the two stage runways to complete them.

Ebenezer Scrooge is visited by the ghosts of Christmas past, present and future. We had reservations about the casting of Rhys Ifans in this role but, like the best actors, he’s completely unrecognisable in it as the businessman who realises there’s more to life than money – and utterly convincing and moving.

Warchus writes in the programme: ‘Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol as an urgent rallying cry for social responsibility and compassion. Participating in life means that we inevitably become more aware of others. ‘Prejudice cannot survive proximity’, as they say.’

Elsewhere, John Dagleish (an Olivier Award winner for Sunny Afternoon) plays family man Bob Cratchit sympathetically. Myra McFadyen is as memorable as the sour-faced Ghost of Christmas Past as Golda Rosheuvel, in sunglasses, as the Ghost of Christmas Present.

But it is Tiny Tim (we’re guessing either Ethan Quinn, Toby Eden or Lenny Rush at this performance) who could thaw the most frozen of hearts.

This is the sixth play that Warchus has directed at this venue during his time in the top job and we can’t recall ever being so moved here.

It’s a terrific achievement to reimagine such a familiar classic in such a memorable fashion but also to enhance the Christmas element of it in so many new ways.

It’s press night is tonight. There aren’t many tickets left before it closes on 20 January. Don’t be the humbug who misses out on this theatrical magic.

  • Picture via Facebook courtesy Old Vic. Tickets
  • Enjoyed this review? Follow its author on Twitter @NeilDurham, email and check us out on Instagram and Facebook


  1. Pingback: MONSTAS SHORTLIST: Revival of the year: 2017 | monstagigz
  2. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: Mood Music starring Ben Chaplin and Seána Kerslake at the Old Vic | monstagigz
  3. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child (Parts 1 and 2) | monstagigz
  4. Pingback: AWARDS: MONSTAS: Our best TV of 2018 so far | monstagigz
  5. Pingback: INVESTIGATION: Should you join your favourite theatre as a member? | monstagigz
  6. Pingback: PREVIEW: 9 reasons why we can’t wait for February 2019 | monstagigz
  7. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: The End Of History starring David Morrissey, Lesley Sharp, Kate O’Flynn & Sam Swainsbury at the Royal Court | monstagigz
  8. Pingback: PREVIEW: 9 reasons why we can’t wait for October 2019 starring Shakespears Sister | monstagigz
  9. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: On Bear Ridge starring Rhys Ifans, Rakie Ayola, Jason Hughes & Sion Daniel Young at the Royal Court | monstagigz
  10. Pingback: Q&A/THEATRE REVIEW: Faith Healer at the Old Vic starring Michael Sheen, Indira Varma & David Threlfall | monstagigz
  11. Pingback: PREVIEW: 9 reasons why we can’t wait for December 2020 starring Palladium pantomime | monstagigz
  12. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: A Christmas Carol starring Simon Russell Beale, Patsy Ferran & Eben Figueiredo at the Bridge Theatre | monstagigz
  13. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: What If If Only starring John Heffernan & Linda Bassett at the Royal Court | monstagigz
  14. Pingback: THEATRE REVIEW: A Christmas Carol-ish by Mr Swallow starring Nick Mohammed & Sarah Hadland | monstagigz

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.